Skip to content 
Sleep is a vital aspect of our overall health and wellbeing. It’s often the first part of most people’s routine they neglect when life gets in the way. However, securing a solid eight hours can improve your mood and productivity, help you keep those extra pounds off, and allow your brain to function at total capacity.
Hence, choosing bed sheets isn’t a task to be taken lightly, as you’re probably aware if you’re reading this guide.
Comforters play an essential role in keeping you warm and making sure that you’re comfortable in bed, so choosing the right one could be the difference between a good night’s sleep and a night of restlessness.
In this guide, we’re going to cover the pros and cons of different oversized queen comforters, explaining the features that you should look out for, so you can shop with confidence.
At a Glance – 5 Best Oversized Queen Comforters
- Ryoliving Premium Heavyweight Oversized Queen Comforter – Our #1 Top Pick
- Bare Home Oversized Queen Comforter – Our #1 Budget Pick
- HOMBYS Lightweight Oversized Queen Comforter
- Byourbed Coma Inducer Oversized Queen Comforter
- Kasantex All Season Down Alternative Oversized Queen Comforter
The Benefits of a Good Oversized Queen Comforter
The primary benefit of having a good quality oversized queen comforter is that you’ll feel more comfortable and warm and, as a result, get a better night’s sleep.
That sounds simple, right? It is, but you might be surprised by just how many additional benefits you could experience simply by catching enough Zs each night.
Boost Your Immune System
When you sleep, the cells in your body also recharge so they can fight off any infections that come their way. During this time of restfulness, your body also has a chance to heal any injuries, preparing you for the day ahead.
Improve Your Mood
When you get enough good quality sleep, you wake up feeling well-rested and prepared for the day ahead. You’ll have more energy which, in turn, will allow you to cope with any challenges that come at you throughout the day.
Prevent Weight Gain
When you don’t get enough sleep, your body begins to produce a hormone that makes you feel more hungry while suppressing the production of the hormone that makes you feel full. This can quickly lead to weight gain if those sleepless nights start to add up.
Strengthen Your Heart
A lack of sleep results in releasing a stress hormone called cortisol that makes your heart work harder. Eventually, this can lead to problems like heart attacks and high blood pressure.
Improve Cognitive Function
Studies have shown that getting enough sleep improves your memory and general cognitive function significantly.
All of these benefits are just from 8 hours of sleep! So now you see why selecting a good comforter is so essential.
Some comforters can have a calming, soothing effect as well. If this sounds like something you’d like to learn more about, check out our guide to the best twin-size weighted blankets/comforters.
What to Consider When Buying an Oversized Queen Comforter
You might think that one comforter is much like any other comforter, but that’s where you’d be wrong. There are so many factors that differentiate one product from the next, and knowing how comforters can differ is the first step towards choosing the best one for you.
You might have a particular style in mind, such as farmhouse designs or a particular color you like (for example, you might want blue sheets), but no matter your individual tastes, there are a few important things to consider when choosing any type of bedding.
Material
Comforters are filled with layers of soft material to hold as much warmth as possible. This material could be cotton, wool, silk, down, polyester, or even bamboo.
Benefits of Cotton
- Breathable
- Soft
- Long-lasting
- Sustainable
- Naturally occurring
- Low maintenance
Benefits of Wool
- Naturally hypoallergenic
- Biodegradable & sustainable
- Naturally occurring
- Temperature regulating
Benefits of Silk
- Hypoallergenic
- Temperature regulating
- Good for skin & hair
- Lightweight
- Soft
Benefits of Down
- Extremely warm (but not temperature regulating)
- Thicker
- Naturally occurring
Benefits of Polyester
- Durable
- Dries quickly
- Low cost
- Easy to clean
If you particularly like the feeling of cotton, we have a guide to the best prima cotton sheets.
Cleaning
Check the label before purchasing to find out the best way to clean the comforter. Ideally, you want one that is durable and long-lasting and one that is relatively easy to wash.
Fill Power
Fill power is a measurement of how thick and fluffy the filling of the comforter is. Traditionally, it referred to the amount of space one ounce of down occupies, but today many different materials are used inside comforters, and it’s perfectly possible to adapt the measurement.
The following guidelines will help you find the perfect fill power:
- 400 or less – Usually best for use in the summer, particularly if you’re prone to overheating.
- 400-600 – This is a great all-around thickness that can be used at any time of the year.
- 600-800 – Ideal for winter use or if you’re especially susceptible to the cold.
- 800+ – You’ll only want a comforter this thick if you’re going to be facing icy conditions.
Construction
How a comforter is constructed – particularly the interior stitching – impacts its durability, effectiveness, and overall comfort level. If the seam isn’t of high quality, the filling of the comforter can move around, making it lumpy and resulting in an uneven temperature.
The different construction methods are as follows:
- Baffle box – the best, most popular, and most expensive option, baffle box comforters have checkered stitching (sometimes called box stitch), and each filled box has fabric baffles on the walls.
- Channel – parallel channels of filler material run up and down the comforter. Unfortunately, this allows the filler to move around quite a lot.
- Gusseted – usually, gusseted comforters also have a baffle box construction. They also have fabric walls around the sides, adding more weight.
- Quilt stitched – they look fairly similar to baffle box comforters, but there are no baffle boxes inside, so make sure you check carefully before purchasing.
Thread Count
Whatever fabric you choose for the exterior of your comforter, you’re going to want to pay attention to the thread count, as this is a key indicator of quality.
It refers to the number of threads in a square inch of fabric. A higher thread count indicates that the fabric is more tightly woven and therefore fine, but not necessarily that the fabric is better (although this is often the case).
A badly constructed fabric will feel stiff and uncomfortable even if it has a high thread count, so bear that in mind when you’re shopping around.
Thread count is particularly important to consider when choosing bed sheets.
Price
Setting a realistic budget will help you determine what type of comforter you can afford. This can also help you prioritize which features are most important to you.
Generally speaking, comforters can cost anywhere between $50 and $200.
However, just because a comforter is more expensive doesn’t necessarily mean it’s better. It’s important to weigh the pros and cons of the product against the price to determine whether it’s good value for money.
Product Criteria
In this section, I’ll cover the main considerations I took into account when selecting my top 5 oversized queen comforters.
Comfort Level
This is based on the thread count, the exterior fabric, and interior filling, as well as the type of stitching that has been used. Most importantly, it’s based on how well I slept when I tested out each comforter.
Style
Comforters aren’t just about warmth and comfort. They make up a large part of your bedroom’s overall decor. Therefore it’s important that they look the part.
There are different designs available – such as farmhouse style, which I mentioned earlier – so I took the overall appearance of each comforter into account.
Features
You might not think it at first glance, but some comforters do have better features than others. These might include being machine washable, reversible, having interior box-stitching, or including temperature regulating filling.
Needless to say, the more features a comforter has, the better value for money it will be.
Budget
Paying a higher price doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll get a higher performing product. To work out the true value for money of a comforter, weigh the price against its features, style, and comfort.
I have included comforters across the price spectrum to help you find one that suits your budget.
Reviews
Sometimes product descriptions can be misleading, so the best way to get to the truth about a particular comforter is to read reviews by verified customers. These often give insights that will play an important role in your decision-making process.
As such, I have considered the reviews for each product carefully.
Top 5 Oversized Queen Comforters
Ryoliving Premium Heavyweight Oversized Queen Comforter – Our #1 Top Pick
| Find it Here. |
Bare Home Oversized Queen Comforter – Our #1 Budget Pick
| Find it Here. |
HOMBYS Lightweight Oversized Queen Comforter
| Find it Here |
Byourbed Coma Inducer Oversized Queen Comforter
| Find it Here |
Kasantex All Season Down Alternative Oversized Queen Comforter
| Find it Here |
Ryoliving Premium Heavyweight Oversized Queen Comforter
The Ryoliving Premium Heavyweight Oversized Comforter is one of the best on the market and definitely gave the best night’s sleep out of all the comforters I tested! I tend to run cold, so the extra thickness worked perfectly to keep me toasty all night.
The 100% cotton exterior to this sumptuously warm comforter gives a luxurious feel. Inside, the traditional down filling is soft and odorless, and thanks to the interior box stitch, it stays in place to ensure consistent warmth.
It’s reassuring to know that the duck feather and down filling has passed the RDS, Downpass, and Oeko-Tex professional certification, so you can get a sound night’s sleep knowing you’ve purchased this comforter in confidence!
When you’re purchasing a product this thick and bulky, it’s always a concern thinking about how you’ll wash it – especially since the Ryoliving Queen Comforter is durable enough to last for years. However, there’s no need to worry as you can put it in the washing machine on a gentle cold wash.
Pros
- Machine washable.
- 100% cotton exterior.
- Extremely warm and comfortable.
- The filling stays in place.
- 30-day money-back guarantee.
- Ethically sourced down.
Cons
- It can be noisy when you move around at night.
- Not as large as some other oversized Queen comforters.
Bare Home Oversized Queen Comforter
If you’re working to a tight budget, the Bare Home Oversized Queen Comforter is a great product that feels luxurious without the luxury price tag. What I love most about it is that it proves you can find an affordably priced product without compromising on quality.
Given that this comforter is perfect for all seasons, the reversible black and grey design means you won’t ever get bored of looking at it – simply turn it over for a refreshed look. Or, if you prefer your bedding to be a little more vibrant, there are plenty of other color combinations to choose from.
The poly fiber filling is an excellent alternative to duck down if you prefer not to use animal products, and the box stitching pattern prevents it from moving around. I personally prefer the softness of down, but poly-fiber still provides plenty of warmth even if it doesn’t quite give the same sense of padding.
Like the Ryoliving comforter above, this product also comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Pros
- The microfiber exterior is exceptionally soft.
- Polyfiber filling retains warmth.
- Box stitch design.
- 30-day money-back guarantee.
- Reversible design.
Cons
- Seams can come apart in the washing machine – it’s best to hand wash.
- Feels quite heavy.
HOMBYS Oversized Queen Comforter
A more lightweight option is the HOMBYS Oversized Queen Comforter. It has been designed with a hollow bamboo and microfiber filling that does an exceptionally good job of regulating the temperature. It is slow heating and fast cooling, making it an ideal summer or transitional season comforter.
Bamboo fabric is extra soft, and in fact, it even feels reminiscent of silk. I really liked this product because it was lightweight compared to some of the other comforters I tested. It still keeps you warm without that claustrophobic feeling that sometimes comes with heavy bedding.
The main thing to be aware of is that if you’re in a cooler climate or your body naturally runs cold, this product probably won’t be right for you. However, if you run hot or you share your bed with a partner, the cooling effect is fantastic.
Pros
- Bamboo viscose shell.
- Temperature regulating.
- Lightweight.
- Box-stitch design.
- Machine washable.
Cons
- Not very warm for colder seasons.
- Looks like a sleeping bag – thin design.
Byourbed Coma Inducer Oversized Queen Comforter
The crushed velvet Byourbed Coma Inducer Oversized Queen Comforter is a solid choice, offering a reversible design that includes an ultra-warm Sherpa for something a little chicer. This is also one of the biggest oversized Queen comforters on the market, adding to its overall coziness.
The main downside to this option is that the filling is made of polyester, a material that is great at trapping heat but poor for releasing it again. This makes for a sweaty night’s sleep if you’re not in a very cool room!
Fortunately, Byourbed’s Comforter is machine washable, but it may be too big for some washing machines due to its large size.
Pros
- Chic design.
- Elegant color.
- Extremely warm.
- Reversible design, including ultra-warm Sherpa.
Cons
- Too large for some washing machines.
- The polyester lining doesn’t release heat.
Kasantex All Season Oversized Queen Comforter
The contemporary styling of the Kasantex Oversized Queen Comforter makes it a very attractive option, complete with a box-stitched design and a down alternative filling.
This comforter is perfect for all seasons, but unlike the rather thin all-season comforter by HOMBY, it retains its sense of coziness with a well-padded design. Inside, the hydrophilic fiberfill is warm and comfortable, but most importantly, it’s easy to maintain and doesn’t feel too heavy.
It’s great to see so many different color options to choose from, meaning that you can match the comforter to the interior style of your house. Overall, this is a great all-season comforter.
Pros
- Box stitched design.
- Well padded yet temperature regulating.
- Many color options.
- Moisture absorbent hydrophilic fiberfill.
Cons
- Machine washing can damage the product.
- Not as durable as some other comforters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Best Oversized Queen Comforter – My Verdict
Overall, I found that the Ryoliving Premium Heavyweight Oversized Comforter performed best all round. Thanks to its duck down and feather filling, it offers an unbeatable level of comfort, plenty of warmth, and a great night’s sleep.
The Bare Home Oversized Queen Comforter is the best choice for anyone working on a tight budget, thanks to the reversible design and soft microfiber exterior. You can sleep well under this comforter knowing that you’ve got great value for your money.
If your body tends to run hot, you should go for the HOMBYS Oversized Queen Comforter, which has an ultra-lightweight, temperature-controlling design.
On the other hand, if the style is your primary concern, the Byourbed Coma Inducer Oversized Queen Comfort offers a chic design with multiple color options and a soft velvet exterior.
Finally, if you want to test out an affordable all-season comforter to see if you like it, the Kasantex Oversized Queen Comforter is a good place to start. It’s very cozy yet manages to maintain that all-important temperature controlling quality.
