Most Comfortable Softest Comforters Ever

Updated July 27, 2022
Why Trust Pillow Insider?

Pillow Insider spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own.

Bottom Line
Pros
Cons
Best of the Best

Sleep Restoration

Hotel Comforter
View on Amazon

Bottom Line

bottom line
Highest Quality This comforter will keep cold sleepers warm and every sleeper comfortable. We loved how safe and cozy we felt wrapped up in this oversized comforter.

Pros

pros
  • Reversible design
  • Easy to clean, dries quick

Cons

cons
  • Might be too thick/warm for hot sleepers
Best Bang for the Buck

Beckham Hotel Collection

1600 Series
View on Amazon

Bottom Line

bottom line
Customer Favorite As if this brand's pillow didn't make sleeping comfortable enough, Beckham Hotel Collection's comforter made us want to hit snooze over and over again.

Pros

pros
  • Washer and Dryer Safe
  • Perfect Temperature Control for All Seasons

Cons

cons
  • Thin Unless Fluffed in Dryer

Italian Luxury

2100 Series
View on Amazon

Bottom Line

bottom line
Softest Touch This comforter was really nice on the skin - smooth and lightweight. It won't keep you warm in icy winters, but it does the trick every other season.

Pros

pros
  • Hypoallergenic for sensitive skin
  • Fade + stain resistant

Cons

cons
  • Requires delicate wash cycle or it'll rip apart

Utopia

Duvet Insert
View on Amazon

Bottom Line

bottom line
Affordable Pick An inexpensive comforter that gets the job done? Look no further than Utopia's comforter, we found it to be the perfect budget pick for anybody who isn't that picky.

Pros

pros
  • Great color selection
  • Reasonable price

Cons

cons
  • Arrives flat if you don't unbox right away

How We Tested

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

Click here for testing insights >
15 Models
Considered
80 Consumers
Consulted
120 Hours
Researched
Buying guide for
Most Comfortable Softest Comforters Ever

A soft comforter is great for keeping warm and snuggling all night. If you’ve ever slept with one, you’d know that the softer, the more comfortable it is, so we’re on a mission to find the softest comforter we can.

However, finding the softest comforter set that’s the right width for your bed and great for different climates can be a daunting task. If you’re allergic, the type of filling and the outer covering of the comforter are also important considerations when shopping for comforters. Luckily, we’ve compiled a list of the incredibly softest ones in the market.

Softness isn’t the only attribute we looked for and tested. In fact, softness was only the start. Instead of trying to whiten an old, yellow comforter – all of these comforters are durable and cost less than $100.

Other Products We Considered

The Pillow Insider editorial team researches hundreds of products based on consumer reviews, brand quality, and value. We then choose a shorter list for in-depth research and testing before finalizing our top picks. These are the products we considered that ultimately didn't make our top 5.

Our Top Products

Best of the Best
Sleep Restoration Hotel Comforter bottom line This comforter will keep cold sleepers warm and every sleeper comfortable. We loved how safe and cozy we felt wrapped up in this oversized comforter.
View on Amazon

Best Bang for the Buck
Beckham Hotel Collection 1600 Series bottom line As if this brand's pillow didn't make sleeping comfortable enough, Beckham Hotel Collection's comforter made us want to hit snooze over and over again.
View on Amazon

Top Pick
Italian Luxury 2100 Series bottom line This comforter was really nice on the skin - smooth and lightweight. It won't keep you warm in icy winters, but it does the trick every other season.
View on Amazon

Top Pick
Utopia Duvet Insert bottom line An inexpensive comforter that gets the job done? Look no further than Utopia's comforter, we found it to be the perfect budget pick for anybody who isn't that picky.
View on Amazon
About the Author Jacob Rollings

Jacob is a pillow and bedding enthusiast who loves experimenting with new pillows and mattresses to help our readers make informed decisions. He possesses broad knowledge of quality bedding including comforters, bedsheets, mattresses, pillows, etc. Jacob experiments and tests new bedding accessories with meticulously researched and detailed, unbiased reviews to ensure that consumers get the most out of their investment. Having tested a variety of bedding items from mattress toppers, unique pillow fillings to comforters and more, Jacob’s know-how of the bedding industry runs deep and continues to expand.

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top